Popular Muslim Gets CRUSHED By Christian Lady!

A conversation between a popular Muslim preacher (Smile 2 Jannah) and a Christian woman quickly turned into a deeper discussion about Jesus, Islam, and the nature of God.

The Christian woman challenged the common Islamic claim that Jesus was a Muslim, arguing that the Jesus revealed in Scripture, does not fit comfortably within Islamic theology.

What began as a discussion over definitions, eventually moved into questions about God as Father, whether Allah has children in any sense, and how Christians and Muslims should interpret their respective scriptures.

What Actually Makes Someone a Muslim?

The Muslim preacher explained that, from an Islamic perspective, a Muslim is someone who submits to God, accepts the revelation given at the time, and believes in the prophet sent to him.

But that broad definition creates problems.

Christians also believe they should submit themselves to God. Simply defining “Muslim” as “one who submits to God” does not prove that every Biblical prophet practiced the religion later revealed through Muhammad.

The Christian woman therefore kept pressing the definition.

Eventually, the preacher gave a more specific description involving belief in God, the messenger of the time, and Islamic articles of faith. Once a definition has been established, however, it must be applied consistently.

Overly broad definitions can produce strange conclusions. Share on X

Someone could claim to “submit to God” while rejecting the Quran entirely, yet Muslims would not ordinarily accept that person as Muslim. Definitions therefore cannot change merely to make Jesus fit into Islam.

Was Jesus Really a Muslim?

Eventually, the preacher acknowledged that according to his Islamic definition, he objectively believed Jesus was Muslim. The Christian woman then challenged him to examine Jesus from the Bible itself.

That becomes important because Jesus constantly described God as His Father.

“After this manner therefore pray ye: Our Father which art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name.” — Matthew 6:9

Jesus also said:

“I and my Father are one.” — John 10:30

The problem is not merely that Jesus submitted Himself to God. Christianity teaches that the eternal Son entered humanity and submitted Himself to the Father while maintaining His divine identity.

So if Muslims want to claim Jesus for Islam, they also have to address what Jesus actually taught about God, Himself, and the Father-Son relationship.

Muhammad Is Not the Father

The discussion also highlights an interesting contrast with Muhammad.

Quran 33:40 explicitly says Muhammad is not the father of any of the Muslim men, identifying him instead as Allah’s messenger.

Christian Scripture, however, repeatedly uses fatherhood and sonship when describing the relationship between God and His people.

“Behold, what manner of love the Father hath bestowed upon us, that we should be called the sons of God…” — 1 John 3:1

God is not presented merely as a distant ruler issuing commands. Christians know Him as Father.

That distinction became increasingly important as the discussion turned toward what the Quran says about Allah having children.

“We Are the Children of God” [Allah Has No Children]

The Christian woman brought up Quran 23:91, which says Allah has taken no offspring. Her argument was straightforward: If Allah has no children, how can he properly be called Father?

The preacher attempted to distinguish between biological children, metaphorical children, adopted children, and other forms of sonship.

But that raises a critical question: Where does the Quran itself make those distinctions?

If someone argues that the Quran only rejects biological sonship, evidence should be produced from the Quran or Hadith establishing that limitation. Otherwise, qualifications are being added to the text rather than drawn from it.

As the discussion summarized the point, if Allah has no children, the natural conclusion is that he is not a father.

Quran 5:18 is an important passage to consider.

The verse reports Jews and Christians saying that they are the children of Allah and His beloved ones. The Quran responds by asking why Allah punishes them for their sins if they truly hold that status.

That reasoning sharply contrasts with the Bible.

“For whom the Lord loveth he chasteneth, and scourgeth every son whom he receiveth.” — Hebrews 12:6

Scripture continues:

“If ye endure chastening, God dealeth with you as with sons…” — Hebrews 12:7

In Hebrews, discipline does not disprove sonship. Fatherly discipline actually demonstrates that believers belong to God.

Jews & Christians understood themselves as God’s children metaphorically, while additionally teaching the Messiah is the Son in a unique and unparalleled sense.

Quran 5:18 therefore becomes important when considering whether Islamic theology allows God to be Father in the same manner Scripture repeatedly describes Him.

The Characteristics of God Matter

The debate later moved toward the characteristics of God and how Scripture should be interpreted.

A discussion about if Jesus lied about the mustard seed (being the smallest).

Jesus was not lying. His words made sense within the agricultural and cultural setting of His audience.

Scripture teaches:

“God is not a man, that he should lie…” — Numbers 23:19

Understanding God’s characteristics therefore matters. Whether we discuss truthfulness, fatherhood, sonship, holiness, or deity, interpretations must remain consistent with what Scripture reveals about God’s nature.

Context Matters

Perhaps the greatest lesson from this exchange is that simply saying “context” does not settle an argument.

Context includes the words surrounding a passage, the chapter, the entire book, related passages, and sometimes the historical and cultural setting.

Different kinds of context also carry different weight.

If another passage in the Quran or Hadith explicitly said that statements about Allah having no son referred only to biological offspring, that would provide strong textual evidence.

A later scholar merely offering an interpretation cannot automatically override the primary text.

Christians must apply the same principle to the Bible.

“Study to shew thyself approved unto God… rightly dividing the word of truth.” — 2 Timothy 2:15

The goal should never be clever slogans or convenient definitions. We must examine the text carefully, follow the argument consistently, and allow Scripture to define its own terms.

For another revealing Christian-Muslim discussion, read the next article. It provides another useful example of why Christians should examine religious claims carefully, understand the context, and remain grounded in what Scripture actually teaches.

WATCH THE VIDEO